Leadership Development

how heat transformed the Paris Olympics in 100 years

[ad_1]

Getty Images British athlete Ernie Harper crosses the finish line of the 1924 Paris Olympics cross-country race (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Athletes competing in the 1924 cross-country race struggled to cross the finish line due to extreme heat (Credit: Getty Images)

From time in saunas to turning off fans, athletes have been bracing for extreme heat at the Olympics. A century on from Paris’ last Olympics, Isabelle Gerretsen and Miriam Quick investigate how climate change has transformed the city and the games.

An unofficial thermometer placed near the start line (probably in the sun) measured an eye-watering 45C (113F), temperatures one newspaper described as “Senegalese”. The heat created a suffocating, putrid atmosphere, given off by the fermentation of the garbage, making it an asphyxiating and unhealthy receptacle for pestilential odours”.

The day of the cross-country race was exceptionally hot – the average daily maximum temperature during the Olympic period in 1924 was 24C (75F). Now, 100 years later, Paris is again host to the Olympic Games, and the Paralympic Games shortly after. And once again, heat is a challenge that athletes and spectators alike may have to contend with.

The difference now is that the climate has changed dramatically since Paris last hosted the Olympics. Average temperatures in the city are significantly higher today than in 1924. Air pollution, on the other hand, has fallen as the city has moved away from fossil fuels, especially coal, and clamped down on car use.

The Paris Olympics of 1924

The Paris Olympics 100 years ago were a much smaller spectacle than today’s – there were 126 events across 17 sports compared to the 329 medal events Paris 2024 will host across 32 sports. A total of 3,089 athletes took part in the 1924 games; 10,500 are competing at the Olympics in 2024. Around 625,000 spectators came out to watch them compete – a fraction of the 15 million people who are expected to attend the games this year. (Read more about how the City of Light changed the Olympics).

Rising heat

Average temperatures in the French capital have increased by 3.1C (5.6F) during the period the 2024 Olympics will be held since 1924, according to a recent report, titled Rings of Fire, written by climate scientists and heat physiologists at the University of Portsmouth in the UK.

During the Paralympics, which take place in late August and early September, average temperatures have warmed by 1C (1.8F) over the past 100 years, the scientists conclude. Overall, annual temperatures have warmed in the French capital by 1.8C (3.2F) since 1924.

Climate change has driven rising temperatures over the past century. In 1924, CO2 levels in the atmosphere globally were around 305 parts per million (ppm). Today they are 419 ppm – an almost 40% increase.

“Heat could be a killer if you aren’t able to get your nutrition and hydration right,” she says. Mohan has previously suffered from diarrhoea, mental fogginess and dehydration after competing in extreme heat. “I have competed in temperatures 40C (104F) or higher before,” she says. “After the competition you really start feeling the effects – your body goes into shutdown mode.”

BBC/Noaa and EPA Global CO2 levels have increased by almost 40% since 1924 (Credit: BBC/Noaa and EPA)BBC/Noaa and EPA

Global CO2 levels have increased by almost 40% since 1924 (Credit: BBC/Noaa and EPA)

Sarah Safieddine, a climate scientist at the French National Centre for Scientific Research, says it is still too early to predict whether a heatwave will hit Paris during the Olympics.

But the national weather service, Météo France, has said that this summer is likely to be warmer than average. The recent El Niño, which ended in April, is still influencing global temperatures, says Safieddine. “So we have global temperatures that are higher on average than previous years,” she says.

Getty Images The climate has changed dramatically since Paris last hosted the Olympics, with average temperatures rising by 3.1C (5.6F) (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

The climate has changed dramatically since Paris last hosted the Olympics, with average temperatures rising by 3.1C (5.6F) (Credit: Getty Images)

Summer temperatures in Paris, like many major cities, are intensified by the “urban heat island effect”, when concrete roads and buildings absorb more heat than in rural areas. But there is some relief. “We are lucky to have big parks in the middle of the city which act as urban cool islands,” says Safieddine. (Read more about how green spaces, white roads and water features can help keep cities cool during deadly heatwaves).

Extreme heat has become much more common in Paris since the city last hosted the Olympics. In 1924, there were 29 “hot” days, with maximum temperatures of 25C (77F) or higher, and two “scorching” days, when temperatures reached 30C (86F) or higher. Last year, there were 86 hot days and 26 scorching days in Paris, according to the Rings of Fire report.

BBC/Météo-France Extreme heat has become much more common in the French capital since 1924 (Credit: BBC/Météo-France)BBC/Météo-France

Extreme heat has become much more common in the French capital since 1924 (Credit: BBC/Météo-France)

“The hottest place I have raced was the Paralympic final in Tokyo. There was even a sign as you got off the bus warning you how hot it was outside,” says Benjamin Pritchard, UK Paralympic rower.

The rower says that he struggles with thermoregulation due to his disability, a spinal cord injury that means he is paralysed from the waist down. “I have done a lot of work on cooling methods and appropriate warm-up techniques to ensure that the heat doesn’t affect me too poorly,” he says.

Extreme heat has a detrimental impact on athletic performance, says Mike Tipton, co-author of the Rings of Fire report and professor of physiology at the University of Portsmouth’s Extreme Environments Laboratory in the UK.

“As the temperature goes up, you get a reduction in performance – marathon performance declines by about one minute for every 1C (1.8F) increase in air temperature above 15C (59F),” says Tipton.

The ideal temperature for continuous endurance, such as cycling or running, is 11C (51.8F), says Tipton.

Getty Images The Notre Dame was caked in thick, black dust in the 1920s (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

The Notre Dame was caked in thick, black dust in the 1920s (Credit: Getty Images)

It’s not just athletes’ physical performance that is diminished by heat, he adds. “Heat changes your cognitive function in terms of complex decision making, makes you more irritable and more agitated, reduces motivation, and decreases mood.”

This means that scorching temperatures can also impact more “passive sporting events”, such as archery or shooting, where the “margins of error are very small”, he says. (Read more about the sinister ways heatwaves warp the mind.) Acclimatising to high temperatures is now a critical part of training for athletes, says Tipton. “If you get your heat preparation wrong, it’s a risk to life and limb.” 

Medal Moments

Want to read more about the Olympics? Sign up for Medal Moments, your free global guide to Paris 2024, delivered daily to your inbox throughout the Games.

Mohan is preparing for high temperatures at the Paris Olympics by spending up to an hour in saunas several times a week and turning off the fans while doing her indoor cycling training.

“Being an outdoor sport, whatever conditions you can think of, we have trained in them,” says Pritchard.

Organisers say they are taking a number of precautions to protect athletes from extreme heat. Outdoor endurance events such as the marathon and triathlon will start early, at 8am, when it is cooler, and athletes will have access to water stations and shaded areas at regular intervals, says Lambis Konstantinidis, executive director of planning and coordination at the Paris Olympics. The triathlon will be postponed if the temperature rises above 32.2C (90F), Konstantinidis says.

The AC question

Instead, the village will be cooled by a geothermal system which pumps water from deep below the ground to keep indoor temperatures 6C (10.8F) lower than outside, according to the organising committee. More than 9,000 trees have also been planted in the Olympic and Paralympic villages to provide natural cooling. The “natural freshness” of the River Seine will also help cool the city centre, says Konstantinidis.

Whatever conditions you can think of, we have trained in them – Benjamin Pritchard

Some delegations, including the US, have said that they plan to bring their own air-conditioning units, for athletes’ rooms. “In our conversations with athletes, this was a very high priority and something that the athletes felt was a critical component in their performance capability,” Sarah Hirshland, chief executive of the Olympic and Paralympic Committee leadership committee, said during a press briefing in June.

Mohan says she has “mixed feelings” about the lack of air conditioning in the village. She says she understands organisers’ commitment to sustainability but is worried about the impact heat will have on her health and recovery following the triathlon. “Recovery is very important for athletes,” she says. “I want to be safe. I don’t want to come back injured and I don’t want to not have my best performance on the day.”

The organisers of the games have said that Paralympic delegations will be provided with one free air-conditioning unit for every three athletes for medical reasons, as some athletes experience thermoregulation problems.

BBC/Météo-France Athletes expressed concern about the lack of air con at the Paris Olympics. Analysis shows hot night temperatures have become more common since 1924 (Credit: BBC/Météo-France)BBC/Météo-France

Athletes expressed concern about the lack of air con at the Paris Olympics. Analysis shows hot night temperatures have become more common since 1924 (Credit: BBC/Météo-France)

Toxic air

It’s difficult to know exactly how polluted Parisian air was in 1924, when air quality monitoring was in its infancy. There are some records dating back to the early 20th Century, such as measurements of suspended dust from industrial processes or measurements of atmospheric electricity. The Eiffel Tower was an ideal structure for taking these measurements and scientists have used these records to infer smoke pollution levels in the French capital in the 1890s.

But these records are not directly comparable to those made today. The closest equivalent is data on levels of particulates: microscopic particles released by burning fossil fuels and from traffic exhausts.

Heat could be a killer if you aren’t able to get your nutrition and hydration right – Pragnya Mohan

Particulate levels in 1920s Paris may well have been about 100 micrograms per cubic metre, estimates Giles Harrison, professor of atmospheric physics at the University of Reading in the UK. This is about five times higher than pollution levels today, BBC analysis reveals.

The main sources of Parisian pollution in 1924 were coal-powered factories and domestic heating as well as motor vehicles, says Harrison.

The 1924 Stade de Colombes Olympic stadium, located in north-west Paris, was surrounded by factories, says Catherine Radtka, a historian of science at the French National Conservatory of Arts and Crafts.

“There were tyre factories, sugar and alcohol refineries and gas plants in the area, emitting fumes, dust and noxious gases,” says Radtka. “There were already complaints from farmers at the beginning of the 20th Century…they said the fumes were destroying their crops.” Physicians had also started sounding the alarm about the health risks of air pollution, she says.

Iconic landmarks, such as the Notre Dame, were caked in thick, black dust. “Everything was black in Paris because of the smog,” says Radtka.

Getty Images The 1924 Stade de Colombes Olympic stadium was surrounded by factories emitting noxious fumes (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

The 1924 Stade de Colombes Olympic stadium was surrounded by factories emitting noxious fumes (Credit: Getty Images)

In 2023, by contrast, monthly levels of large particulates (PM10) in the city averaged 19 micrograms per cubic metre of air – a five-fold reduction compared with 1924.

Much of this improvement has occurred relatively recently. In 2003, monthly PM10 levels still averaged 67 micrograms per cubic metre, but air quality improved in the decades since as the city has prioritised cyclists and pedestrians over cars. Levels of the smallest, most dangerous particles, measuring less than 2.5 microns across (known as PM2.5), have fallen by similar proportions since 2003.

BBC/Copernicus Climate Change and Atmosphere Monitoring Services Parisian air improved over the past two decades as Paris moved away from fossil fuels and curbed car use (Credit: BBC/Copernicus Climate Change and Atmosphere Monitoring Services)BBC/Copernicus Climate Change and Atmosphere Monitoring Services

Parisian air improved over the past two decades as Paris moved away from fossil fuels and curbed car use (Credit: BBC/Copernicus Climate Change and Atmosphere Monitoring Services)

Mohan hopes to swim in the Seine at the Paris Games. “Growing up, I never got to swim in my own river in Ahmedabad because it was so polluted,” she says. “It’s scary that in future the triathlon might not be an outdoor sport due to climate change.”

Extreme heat is already changing her sport. Mohan says she can no longer train outdoors in India due to the scorching temperatures. This reality has forced her to move away from her home and train in London instead. The conditions faced by the cross-country runners in the 1924 Olympics are becoming increasingly common for athletes. Mohan has competed in temperatures exceeding 40C (104F) and 50-80% humidity.

“If I had a choice, I wouldn’t have done those races,” she says. “But as athletes we are wired to perform our best and to keep pushing ourselves.”   

The graphs in this story were created by Diana Mota.

For more science, technology, environment and health stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and X.

[ad_2]

Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button